So after staring at this broken thing for a month, a little light bulb goes off and I decide to decoupage it! I stripped it of the strings and glued the head back on. I really wanted it to be a music theme. I decided I would print out small squares featuring the album covers of different bands/albums we liked, and cut them out individually.
Before I started the decoupage process, I gently sanded the surface of the guitar (only where I was going to be glueing) and wiped off all the remaining dust
Next, I took the individual pictures and laid them out on the guitar to sort of get a basic idea about how I wanted it to look. Then, one by one, I brushed Modge Podge on the back of each tile and glued them to the surface, gently smoothing any bubbles out. I repeated this process over and over until I had the entire face of the guitar covered.
Once it was dry, I used an all purpose clear acrylic gloss coat to seal the deal and create a water resistant finish. (Obviously, you should do this outside, or in a well ventilated space)